Christmas gifting can get expensive, especially for teachers who would love to give their students a little something before the holiday break. When you have an entire classroom to think about, even small gifts can quickly add up. And if you’re hoping to find something that’s inexpensive, useful, and not another bag of candy, the options can feel pretty limited.
That’s why I love the idea of turning something as simple as a colorful eraser into an adorable Christmas favor!
These little popsicle-shaped erasers are already cute on their own, but with a few pieces of colorful cardstock, you can dress them up as Santa Claus, a Christmas elf, Rudolph the reindeer, or a cheerful snowman.
I think the kids will get such a kick out of these funny little characters. And once the Christmas decorations come off, they’ll still have a useful eraser to keep in their pencil case and use long after the holidays are over.
Another thing I love about this DIY is that you can make the favors in bulk without spending hours putting them together. Cut all your paper pieces at once, arrange them into little piles, and then assemble each character. You could even make just one design for the whole class if you’re short on time.
I recommend using cardstock rather than regular craft paper. It’s sturdier and holds its shape much better, especially for Santa hats, reindeer antlers, and elf ears.
And please don’t worry about making every little detail perfect! If a particular shape looks too complicated, simplify it. A basic triangle makes a perfectly cute Santa hat, and simple branching antlers will look just as adorable on Rudolph.
The fun is really in the presentation, and these little Christmas characters are sure to bring a few smiles when it’s time to hand out the classroom favors.
P.S: This post contains affiliate links from Amazon and other retailers. If you make a purchase through these links, I will receive a small commission. Pls check Privacy Policy and T&C for more information.)
What You’ll Need to Make These DIY Christmas Favors

You don’t need many supplies, and you may already have most of the crafting materials at home or in your classroom.
- Popsicle-shaped scented erasers — These are the colorful erasers I’m using for this project.
- Colored cardstock — Red, green, brown, white, black, orange, yellow, peach, and pink for the hats, antlers, beards, scarves, and little details.
- Small googly eyes — These give the Christmas characters their funny expressions.
- Sharp scissors or a precision craft knife — Scissors are fine for larger shapes; a precision craft knife makes intricate antlers and holly leaves easier to cut. Adults only, and use a cutting mat underneath.
- Glue or removable adhesive dots — Glue the paper layers together, and use removable dots on the plastic cases.
- Double-sided tape — Another option if you don’t have adhesive dots.
- Black marker — For smiles and other tiny features.
- Small red pom-poms (optional) — For Rudolph’s nose, or simply use a red paper circle.
If you don’t have googly eyes, you can easily make your own using white cardstock or even regular white paper. Just cut out small circles and draw a black dot in the center of each one to make the eyes.
You don’t need to buy everything on this list. Try removable adhesive on one case first, so the children can take off the decorations and use the erasers afterward.
Easy DIY Christmas Favors for Teachers to Give Students
Here are four Christmas characters using the same popsicle-shaped erasers. Choose your favorites, or make all four.
1. DIY Santa Christmas Favor for Kids in the Classroom

How cute is this little Santa? The bright pink popsicle top becomes part of Santa’s face, while the white paper beard gives him that unmistakable Christmas look.
Cut a slightly curved red cardstock triangle for the hat, a white strip for the trim, and a little white circle for the pom-pom. Glue the pieces together. A simple triangle is fine too.
Cut Santa’s beard from white cardstock, giving it a rounded scalloped edge. For the mustache, cut two smaller curved pieces that meet in the middle.
Attach two googly eyes to the case, then add the mustache, beard, and a peach paper circle for the nose. Fix the finished hat above the pink popsicle top using removable adhesive.
Finish by cutting a narrow black paper belt and a little yellow square buckle. Attach them near the bottom of the case.
An easier option: Skip the separate mustache and belt. A red paper hat, two eyes, and one large white beard are enough to make Santa adorable.
2. DIY Christmas Elf Favors That Will Be a Hit With Kids

I think this little elf has the cutest expression of all four characters! The pointy ears and oversized green hat make it look like one of Santa’s little helpers.
Begin by cutting a tall, slightly curved triangle from green cardstock. Add a small yellow circle at the tip and a red strip with a zigzag edge along the bottom. Glue these paper pieces together.
Cut two pointed ears from peach-colored cardstock. Attach two googly eyes to the eraser case and make a small smile with a black marker on a removable paper piece, if you’d rather not draw on the case.
Add the pointed ears along each side, two pink paper circles for cheeks, a red zigzag collar below the face, and two little yellow circles for buttons. Attach the green hat above the colorful top.
Green, orange, or pink erasers can all make funny little Christmas elves.
An easier option: Make the hat a plain green triangle and skip the cheeks and buttons. The ears and eyes give it plenty of personality.
3. DIY Reindeer Christmas Favors From Teachers to Students

Rudolph is another adorable option, and the brown popsicle erasers are particularly nice for this design. Kids will recognize him as soon as they see the antlers and red nose.
Cut two antlers from brown cardstock. A simple branching shape with two or three points on each antler is enough. Once you’ve cut one good set, trace it as a template for the rest.
Cut two little brown ears and two smaller peach inner-ear shapes. Glue the peach pieces to the brown ones, then attach the antlers and ears behind the rounded top of the eraser case.
Add two googly eyes to the front and a red cardstock circle for Rudolph’s famous nose. A little red paper bow below the face adds a lovely Christmas touch. You can cut one flat bow shape rather than assembling separate pieces.
An easier option: Use simple Y-shaped antlers and skip the ears and bow. A red nose and googly eyes do most of the work.
4. Budget-Friendly DIY Snowman Christmas Favors for Kids

The blue popsicle erasers are perfect for these little snowmen! I love the contrast of the bright blue top, black hat, and cheerful red scarf.
Cut a black cardstock rectangle with slightly angled sides and a long narrow strip for the brim. Glue them together into a top hat. Add a red band, and if you’d like, two tiny green holly leaves and red paper berries.
Attach two googly eyes to the front of the case. Cut an orange cardstock triangle for the carrot nose and position it below the eyes.
Make a smile from little black paper circles, and add two larger circles lower down for buttons. A small hole punch can make all those round pieces much quicker.
Cut a long red strip for the scarf, plus a shorter strip to hang down at one side. Make tiny notches for fringe, then attach the scarf and the completed hat.
An easier option: Use a plain black top hat with a red band and draw the smile on a small white paper piece instead of cutting individual dots.
Tips for Making These Christmas Classroom Favors in Bulk
If you’re making favors for an entire classroom, prepare them in batches rather than finishing each character one at a time. Decide how many Santas, elves, reindeer, and snowmen you need, or choose just one or two designs.
Cut all the pieces for each character together and sort them into little containers. Glue the layers of cardstock together before attaching anything to the eraser cases. That keeps assembly simple.
Make one complete favor before tracing the remaining pieces, so you can check that the hat, antlers, ears, and scarf fit the actual product.
Small pieces such as googly eyes or pom-poms can be a choking hazard for very young children. Keep this craft for an age-appropriate classroom and let adults handle precision knives.
A Cute Non-Candy Christmas Favor Kids Can Actually Use
I love Christmas classroom favors that don’t have to be expensive or complicated to feel special. These little DIY erasers can be made inexpensively in bulk, don’t involve candy, and give children something they can continue using after Christmas.
Arrange the finished characters in a small basket filled with red and green shredded paper and let the children choose their favorites. I think half the fun will be watching them decide between Santa, Rudolph, an elf, and a snowman!
And if you’re preparing these for a large class, don’t feel that you need all four designs. Even one little Christmas character made with a few pieces of cardstock is a lovely way to send your students off for the holidays with a smile.
Also Check Out:
23 DIY Christmas Gifts to Make with Kids | Cheap But Look Expensive
Inexpensive Christmas Gifts for Teacher Coworkers (Under $10)
DIY Homemade Holiday Gift Ideas Teachers Would Appreciate




