Thrift store Christmas gifts are having a real moment this year, and I want you to not miss this because it might surprise you how sensible and meaningful this can be.
An item ending up at a thrift store rarely means something was a reject. More often, someone simply had too much of it or moved on to a different style, and that has nothing to do with whether it will make sense for you or the person you’re giving it to.
The goal is to shop with the recipient in mind rather than your own taste for thrifting, and to pick pieces that are free of stains, scratches, or obvious wear so the gift never screams it is secondhand.
Pair a great find at a second hand store with something homemade, like a batch of fresh cookies or pick one from my homemade gifts, and you’ll end up with a Christmas gift basket that will feels both thoughtful and surprising. With this guide I will walk you through exactly what to look for and how to put it all together to make the most goregous gifts.
P.S: This post contains affiliate links from Amazon and other retailers. If you make a purchase through these links, I will receive a small commission. Pls check Privacy Policy and T&C for more information.)
Why Go Thrifting for Christmas Gifts
Thrift stores are full of good deals that make just as much sense for gift giving as they do for shopping for yourself. A barware set or a full glassware collection often shows up in great condition, and there’s no reason to pay full price for new when a secondhand version looks just as good on a shelf.
Thrift stores are also one of the best places to find classic and vintage pieces that department stores stopped carrying years ago, which makes them perfect if your recipient loves anything with a vintage feel.
Seasonal items are another win. A Christmas china set or holiday plate collection can cost a lot when it’s new and in season, but the same set often turns up secondhand once someone decides they no longer need it or picked up a different one. None of that makes the piece less special. It just means the timing worked out in your favor.
What Not to Gift From a Thrift Store
Some categories are safer to skip no matter how good the price looks. Shoes are one of them, even ones that look barely worn, since fit and comfort are too personal to gamble on.
Secondhand clothing falls in the same camp. Most people have strong feelings about wearing something that belonged to someone else, so it’s better left off the list.
Stained or scratched kitchenware, especially bakeware, should stay on the shelf too. A stain doesn’t wash out of the impression it leaves.
Damaged designer or branded pieces deserve extra caution. A purse or wallet with a recognizable name might seem like an instant win, but a cracked seam, a rip, or a stain undercuts the moment more than a plainer item in perfect condition would.
Puzzles, games, and sets are also worth a second look before they go in the basket. Missing pieces are common and hard to spot until it’s too late.
Electronics and anything mechanical, like clocks or kitchen gadgets, come with their own risk. Without a way to test them in the store, there’s no way to know if they actually work.
Smell is easy to overlook but hard to undo. Old books, candles, and textiles can hold onto odor long after they’re out of the store, so give anything soft or porous a real sniff test first.
Personal care items and anything meant to touch skin, like brushes or pillows, are best bought new no matter how good the secondhand version looks.
Stuffed animals are worth skipping too. There’s no way to know how they were cared for, and they’re difficult to clean thoroughly even when they look fine on the surface.
What Exactly to Buy at Thrift Stores to Make the Best Christmas Baskets
Here are some ideas you probably didn’t think of.
This list is split by who the gift is for, since the approach shifts depending on the relationship. With a coworker, the goal is for the gift to hold up on its own, with nothing that hints it came from a thrift store. Nobody wants to open something and think it looks used.
With a friend, there’s more room to be upfront about it. Mentioning that a piece was too good a deal to pass up can land as charming rather than cheap, since the relationship already has that kind of ease.
Best Thrift Store Finds for a Coworker Christmas Basket
Gift Wrapping Material — Holiday wrapping supplies add up fast once Halloween, Thanksgiving, and Christmas all come around in the same stretch, even when it doesn’t feel like it at checkout. Thrift stores are one of the best places to stock up before that happens. Sets of seasonal wrapping paper often show up bundled together for a fraction of retail price. A set of five holiday rolls found for next to nothing isn’t unusual. Ribbons are worth checking too, along with any other packing or gift wrap accessories on the shelf. It’s worth a look before heading to Michaels or the dollar store, since thrift stores often have bundles at a much lower price.
Recipe Books — Recipe books are one of the more common finds at a thrift store, and plenty of them look barely opened. A little digging usually turns up something worth grabbing. Christmas cookie collections or a vegan holiday cookbook for a plant based recipient can turn into a gift that feels genuinely thoughtful, especially since a good cookbook new almost always runs over twenty dollars. This is one of those finds that works well for a coworker gift basket too. Nobody has to know it came from a thrift store.
Christmas Ornaments — It’s surprising how often Christmas ornaments turn up at thrift stores. Sets originally gifted for a teacher, a retirement, or an occasion like a new baby often get passed along once they no longer fit the recipient’s life, and they can be a great find for a pregnant coworker or anyone celebrating a specific milestone. Full boxed sets show up too. If you come across one, splitting it into smaller bundles of two or three ornaments per person will turn a single box into several individual gifts. Paired with gift wrap, a few homemade cookies, or a small bag of granola or coffee, a handful of ornaments will make an easy coworker basket that will still seem thoughtful.
Christmas Candles — Scented candles land at thrift stores often, usually because someone received a scent that wasn’t quite their preference and passed it along instead of using it. That makes thrift stores a solid spot to find nice candles still sealed or barely touched. Always check for ones that are unused. A candle that’s never been lit makes the gift feel new, even coming from a secondhand shelf.
Best Thrift Store Finds for a Friend Christmas Basket
Cosmetics and other personal care items, along with things like nail polish or hand cream, are still not a good pick from a thrift store, the same as with any other recipient.
Serving Platters — A charcuterie or cookie serving platter, especially a seasonal one, makes a strong gift for a friend, as long as it’s in good shape with no scratches or chips.
Flower Vases — Seasonal vase designs are another strong find. Swapping home decor by season adds up over time, so a secondhand vase can save the recipient from spending on something they’d only use for a few months anyway.
Best Thrift Store Finds for a Family Christmas Basket
Picnic Baskets — Large wicker picnic baskets show up at thrift stores fairly often, and buying one new usually runs high. A secondhand wicker basket in good shape can be the anchor piece for a whole family gift basket.
Wine Carrying Bags — Insulated wine totes are another easy find, and slipping in a bottle before gifting turns a simple bag into a complete gift on its own.
Snow Globes — Snow globes are an easy win for a family with kids. They’re the kind of thing kids never seem to get tired of, and they show up secondhand more than most people expect.
Photo Frames — A matching set of three or four photo frames can work well for family, since you already know their home and what would fit in it. A good frame set new can easily run over thirty dollars, so finding one secondhand is a real save.
Character or Seasonal Mug Sets — A set of mugs featuring a kid’s favorite cartoon character can turn into an instant favorite. Seasonal coffee mug sets are another easy find and work well as a family gift on their own or added into a basket.
Handmade Christmas Stockings — Handmade stocking sets aren’t a rare find either, usually turning up in twos for a couple or in larger sets for a full family. A matching handmade set adds a personal touch that’s hard to find new at the same price.
Ugly Christmas Sweaters — Clothing is one of the few categories where family is a different case than coworkers or friends. A good condition ugly sweater find, washed and packed nicely, can be a fun and welcome addition for family.
Popcorn Bowls — A set of popcorn bowls fits naturally into family movie nights, which a lot of households with kids already have as a regular tradition. Finding a matching popcorn set for the family will make their movie nights even more beautiful.
Best Thrift Store Finds for a Teacher Christmas Basket
Teachers tend to end up with the same kinds of gifts year after year, and after enough holidays and end of year celebrations, a lot of that ends up donated right back to the thrift store. The goal here is to avoid the mugs and small desk clutter they’re likely already tired of, and instead look for things they wouldn’t normally buy for themselves because the price adds up fast across an entire staff.
Accordion File Folders — A sturdy zippered accordion file folder with multiple pockets can easily run over ten dollars new, and that adds up quickly once you’re shopping for ten or more teachers. Finding a few of these secondhand makes it possible to give something genuinely useful without the cost multiplying with every name on the list.
Quality Tote Bags — A sturdy tote bag made of thick fabric, like jute or a heavier canvas, holds up to daily use in a way that a thin cloth version never will. Teachers carry a lot back and forth, so a bag built to handle real weight gets used far more than a decorative one. Thrift stores often have several to choose from, sometimes even handmade ones, and it’s worth checking for tags still attached or fabric that looks untouched.
Candles — A candle lover can never really have enough candles, and good smelling ones get expensive fast. A large, high quality candle found secondhand and still sealed makes an easy gift that feels far more generous than the price suggests.
Best Thrift Store Finds for Secret Santa & White Elephant Gifts
Secret Santa and White Elephant gifts almost always come with a budget cap, and staying under ten or fifteen dollars while still finding something worth unwrapping can be harder than it sounds. Thrift stores are one of the best places to solve that problem.
Music for Vinyl or CD Players — If you happen to know the person still has a CD player or a record player, a Christmas movie soundtrack or a holiday vinyl record makes an easy and specific gift that most people wouldn’t think to buy new.
Novelty and Oddball Finds — Thrift stores are full of the kind of odd, funny items that make a White Elephant gift memorable. Seasonal desk decor with a funny twist, a book full of ridiculous sayings, socks with a silly print, or a pen with a joke on it can all land well. The best White Elephant finds are the ones that get a laugh the moment they’re unwrapped, and thrift stores tend to have exactly that kind of oddball selection.
***
I hope these ideas gave you a fresh way to think about thrift store Christmas gift baskets. Every thrift store is different, and the selection shifts constantly, so it helps to visit every couple of weeks rather than making one trip and calling it done. New stock comes in all the time, and the display changes just as often.
As you find pieces for different gift baskets, keep a running list with each person’s name and what you’ve found for them so far. If you spot a good coworker gift basket item, write it down under their name, along with any wrapping paper idea that fits, like a kid friendly print if there are children involved. Keep adding to each name as you go, whether it’s a Mason jar, an ornament, or anything else that fits their basket.
It also helps to set a spending limit before you start, even while thrifting. It’s easy to end up spending just as much on a thrift store gift basket as you would have on something bought new, which defeats the reason for thrifting in the first place.
Also Check Out:
Here are some Easy DIY food gifts you can make at home that will make great additions to your christmas gift basket.
